
Steve Coogan and Co. go absolutely insane in Hamlet 2
by Gary Sundt
Okay… so Hamlet 2 is about Dana Marschz (Steve Coogan), a struggling actor-turned-high school drama teacher who needs a good play to save the department, which is being cut as a result of a) a tightening budget, and b) the fact that the plays (which have all been adaptations of movies, like Eric Brockovich) aren’t “Oscar-winning or anything.” After reaching deep down in the creative well, the teacher comes up with Hamlet 2, a sequel to the classic Shakespearean masterpiece. The show is about how Hamlet and Jesus Christ travel through time to save everyone that dies at the end of Hamlet (which, according to this movie, is everyone in the play).
Does this sound especially awful? The play definitely is, but the film isn’t. It really isn’t. It’s laugh-out-loud hilarious most of the time, due in no small part to the great cast led by the brilliant Coogan. This was the flick at Sundance that found the people who saw it making fun of the people who didn’t. Appropriate that happened, really. The movie is as mean as any episode of South Park, which might be due to the fact that the co-writer of Hamlet 2, Pam Brady, was one of the writers on both South Park: Bigger, Longer, and Uncut and Team America: World Police.
But enough about how mean the movie is. Let’s focus on how funny it is. Director Andrew Fleming is a hit/miss filmmaker, with the hilarious Dick to his credit, but the utterly underwhelming The In-Laws and Nancy Drew tarnishing his record (The Craft is a fence-sitter – a love it-or-hate it affair). With Hamlet 2, he has been given the gift of Coogan, who carries this movie all the way to the hilarious stage show and beyond. This will no doubt be a star-turning role for the actor, much in the same way Napoleon Dynamite was for Jon Heder. If Coogan’s very expansive resume is any indication, it will not be a mistake.
If it hasn’t become very clear, I like Steve Coogan’s work as Dana Marschz. If the actor were to put on a one man adaptation of this movie (ala Patrick Stewart’s Olivier Award-winning work in A Christmas Carol), I would be the first in line for tickets. However, the film’s supporting cast is just as valuable in making this comedy shine, and I suppose they need love too.
He has his wife (Catherine Keener), who hasn’t been able to get pregnant and thinks Dana’s tight bike shorts are to blame, and their roommate Gary (David Arquette), who doesn’t think much of anything. At school, his life is made difficult by his boss and nemesis, Principal Rocker (Marshall Bell). There is Octavio (Joseph Julian Soria), the streetwise actor-in-the-rough, who the teacher thinks is just a thug until he finds out he has been accepted to Brown. And finally we have the “drama pets,” Rand (Skylar Astin) and Epiphany (Phoebe Strole), who are just hilarious and very much reminded me of similar acquaintances in high school.
And then there is Elisabeth Shue as herself. She plays Dana’s hero and muse. And it is very, very funny.
Everybody in the cast works, and succeeds, at playing it straight against Coogan’s manic energy. In fact, its everyone else’s realistic composure that makes the nutty drama teacher’s behavior just all the more wonderful. This might be exemplified by the unsung hero of Hamlet 2, freshman drama critic Noah Sapperstein (Shea Pepe). Dana desperately pines for the lad’s approval, who responds with logic and reason. And, like all interactions in the film, all logic and reason is taken to insane and illogical extremes.
Proof: Consider the plot of Hamlet 2. When faced with the impending destruction of his precious drama program, the drama critic’s advice for Dana to make an original play, not one based off of movies he has seen. His reaction is to make a sequel.
Note: Hamlet 2 is set in Tucson, AZ, and the film hates the city a whole lot. While I understand to a degree (I used to live there myself), I had an opportunity to personally ask the cast and crew about this, and it became painfully obvious they had never really been to Tucson. In one of the recent television advertisements following this encounter, there can be found a list of individuals and groups that the film apologizes to. The City of Tucson made that list. I’m not saying I’m responsible. I’m just saying.
Note 2: The film insists that everyone dies at the end of Hamlet. This is not true. Most of the really interesting people die, but some people survive. Who would feed the final lines in Shakespeare if some poor schmuck didn’t survive it all?
Running time: 92 minutes. Directed by Andrew Fleming. Produced by Eric Eisner, Leonid Rozhetskin and Aaron Ryder. Written by Pam Brady and Andrew Fleming. Starring Steve Coogan, Catherine Keener, Joseph Julian Soria, Skylar Astin, Phoebe Strole, David Arquette, Marshall Bell, Shea Pepe and Elizabeth Shue. A Focus Features release. Rated R


